Philosophy 417

Abbreviations for Comments on Papers

 


 

 

 

ABC

BEQ

BEV

BFQ

BFV

BG

CBC

CE

DF

DG

EJ

EMC

G

GO

GP

LPC

MAC

NBA

NBC

NBD

NBE

NBO

ND

NE

NMS

NN

NO

NQ

OEP

OGP

OT

SCQ

VG

WA

WM

WR

WT

X

Y

?

A bit confused

Need better explanation of question

Need better explanation of view(s)

Need better formulation of question

Need better formulation(s) of view(s)

Bad grammar

Could be clearer

Counterexample

Doesn't follow

I don’t get this

Excellent job

Need to edit more carefully

Good

Good objection

Good point

Lacking proper citation(s)

Make the argument clearer

Need better argument(s)

Need to be clearer

Need better definition(s)

Need better explanation(s)

Need better discussion(s) of objection(s)

Need definition(s)

Need to elaborate

Not what you meant to say

Not necessarily

Need objection(s)

Not quite right

Overall an excellent paper

Overall a good paper

Need to stay on topic

Special Composition Question

Very good

What is the argument?

What does this mean?

What is the relevance of this?

What is the thesis?

This is wrong

Why?

Huh?

 

 

 


 

Phil 417 Main Page